**1. Precise restatement** Two-household, discrete-time, reduced-form economy. B's earnings are a constant 1. A's earnings next period are a deterministic, decreasing, smooth function of B's *current disposable* income: f(y)=5e^{−k(y−1)}, k=(ln 5)/2. Hidden assumptions: (i) the earnings rule f is policy-invariant (no behavioral or incentive response to taxation); (ii) A's earnings depend only on B's disposable income, not A's own; (iii) redistribution is a pure, costless, instantaneous 50/50 pooling after each earnings realization; (iv) "attracting" is meant locally; (v) "average total income" is the time-average of realized total earnings over the cycle; (vi) baseline convergence "within two periods" refers to this specific reduced form from any initial state. Claim: under (i)–(vi), equalization produces a locally attracting 2-cycle with average total income 4 versus 6. **2. Step-by-step check and independent derivation** - f(1)=5·e⁰=5 ✓. f(3)=5e^{−2k}=5e^{−ln5}=1 ✓. - No redistribution: B's disposable income is 1 after the first update; A's earnings are f(1)=5 after the second. Steady state (5,1), total 6, unique since B is fixed ✓. - Equalization: both get y=(e_A+e_B)/2, so y' = g(y)=(f(y)+1)/2. g(1)=3, g(3)=1 ✓ — a 2-cycle {1,3}. - Stability: g'(y)=f'(y)/2=−k f(y)/2. g'(1)=−5k/2, g'(3)=−k/2; product =5k²/4 =5(ln5)²/16 ≈ 5·2.590/16 ≈ 0.809 <1 ✓, so the cycle is locally attracting. - Fixed point: g is decreasing, so there is a unique fixed point y*≈1.81 (f(1.8)=5^{0.6}≈2.63 vs 2y−1=2.6). |g'(y*)|=k f(y*)/2≈0.805·2.62/2≈1.05>1, so the steady state under equalization is unstable — consistent with convergence to the cycle rather than to y*. - Totals: when y=1, next earnings are (5,1), total 6; when y=3, next earnings (1,1), total 2. Average 4 = (2/3)·6, i.e., a one-third cut ✓. Measured inequality of disposable income is zero every period ✓. All arithmetic checks out. **3. Attempts to break it** - Global vs local attraction: since g is decreasing, g∘g is increasing, so every orbit converges to a fixed point of g², i.e., to y* or a 2-cycle. y* is repelling, so generic orbits go to a 2-cycle; I have not ruled out additional 2-cycles, but the text only claims local attraction, which holds. Not a flaw. - Fine-tuning: the parameters are chosen so that {1,3} is hit exactly; perturbing k would shift the cycle but, given |g'(y*)|>1 is a strict inequality, a nearby attracting 2-cycle persists. The qualitative result is robust to small perturbations; the "exactly one third" is not. - Economic realism: the result rests entirely on the exogenous, policy-invariant lagged externality (assumption i–ii). If f responded to A's own disposable income or to incentives, conclusions could change. But the text explicitly flags this and claims only an existence result ("can"). - The baseline "within two periods" is trivial because B's earnings are constant; that is acknowledged implicitly. No mathematical error found. **4. Novelty** Mechanically this is a one-dimensional decreasing map whose fixed point loses stability and yields a period-2 cycle — the same structure as the cobweb (hog-cycle) model and the backward-bending-offer-curve cycles of Grandmont-type overlapping-generations models. The policy moral — that an intervention introducing lagged feedback can destabilize an otherwise stable system — is the classical Phillips/Friedman point about stabilization policy with lags. The specific "equalization closes a feedback loop" packaging is a neat toy, but it is a special case of these well-known dynamics. **5. Fairness** The sentence is an existence claim ("can") and the text delivers exactly the construction. Minor caveats: "attracting" means locally; the externality is exogenous and policy-invariant; parameters are tuned to make the numbers exact. The text itself disclaims generality, so the summary is fair. {"verdict": "correct", "novelty": "special case or variant of known results", "fair_summary": "yes", "confidence": 5, "one_line": "The arithmetic and stability analysis are correct (f(1)=5, f(3)=1, multiplier 5(ln5)²/16≈0.81<1, average total 4 vs 6), so the tailored existence claim holds, though it is a dressed-up instance of the classical cobweb/lagged-feedback cycle in a decreasing one-dimensional map."}