**1. Precise restatement** Claim: there exist positive mass‑action constants for a system consisting of water (Kw fixed), a neutral monomer M, and singly charged aggregates M_nH⁺ and M_n(−H)⁻ for n = 1…4 (no neutral aggregates, no multiply charged species, no higher aggregates), with ideal activities (activity = concentration), such that along the one‑parameter dilution path (total monomer‑unit concentration C decreasing, nothing else varying), the equilibrium pH equals 7 (i.e. [H⁺]=[OH⁻]) at exactly three values of C and changes sign of (pH−7) at each. Hidden assumptions: ideality, constant Kw and temperature, pure‑water diluent, the specific (contrived) constants, and that the only species present are those listed. **2. Step check and independent re‑derivation** Let u=[M]/c*, y=[H⁺]/√Kw, w=√Kw/c*. Species: [M_nH⁺]/c* = a_n uⁿ y, [M_n(−H)⁻]/c* = b_n uⁿ/y; this is exactly what stepwise aggregation + (de)protonation equilibria give, with a_n,b_n products of constants. Charge balance (units of c*): Q(u,y) = w(y−1/y) + Σ uⁿ(a_n y − b_n/y). Mass balance: C/c* = u + Σ n uⁿ(a_n y + b_n/y). At y=1 with a=(1,12,1,2), b=(7,1,7,1): a−b = (−6,11,−6,1), so Q(u,1) = u⁴−6u³+11u²−6u = u(u−1)(u−2)(u−3). ✓ Roots u=1,2,3. C/c* at y=1: coefficients n(a_n+b_n) = 8, 26, 24, 12, plus the free monomer: C/c* = 9u+26u²+24u³+12u⁴ (the text writes "u+8u", same thing). u=1: 71 ✓; u=2: 18+104+192+192=506 ✓; u=3: 27+234+648+972=1881 ✓. Genuine crossings: need (i) C(u,1) strictly increasing in u — obvious (positive coefficients), so each C corresponds to a unique u₀(C) at y=1; (ii) at fixed C, Q is strictly increasing in y, so the actual equilibrium y lies above/below 1 according to the sign of Q(u₀,1). I verified (ii) directly: with p_n=a_n uⁿy, q_n=b_n uⁿ/y, dQ/d ln y|_C ∝ [w(y+1/y)+Σ(p_n+q_n)]·[u+Σn²(p_n+q_n)] − [Σn(p_n−q_n)]², and by Cauchy–Schwarz (Σn(p−q))² ≤ (Σn(p+q))² ≤ Σ(p+q)·Σn²(p+q), with the water and free‑monomer terms making it strict. This is the "positive Schur complement" claim, confirmed. Since Q(u₀,1) = u₀(u₀−1)(u₀−2)(u₀−3) has simple roots, the solution is basic for C<71, acidic for 71